When you're investing in an engagement ring, you're not just thinking about today—you're thinking about the next 50 years. Will the style you love right now still feel special when you're celebrating your 25th anniversary? Will it look dated in old photos, or timelessly elegant?

As a GIA Graduate Gemologist who's been creating custom engagement rings in Sandy Springs since 1998, I've watched trends come and go. I've seen couples return after a decade, still madly in love with their rings. And I've seen others come back wanting to redesign because their once-trendy choice no longer feels like "them."

Today, one of the most common questions we hear is: "Should I choose a hidden halo or a classic halo?" Both styles are beautiful, but they age very differently. Let me share what I've learned from nearly three decades in the jewelry business.

What Is a Classic Halo?

A classic halo is exactly what it sounds like—a ring of smaller diamonds that surrounds your center stone, creating a glowing "halo" effect. When you look at the ring from above, you immediately see this sparkling frame around the main diamond.

This style became wildly popular around 2010, largely thanks to Kate Middleton's iconic sapphire and diamond engagement ring. Suddenly, everyone wanted that royal, romantic look. The appeal is obvious: a classic halo makes your center stone appear significantly larger (often adding half a carat to a full carat of visual impact) while creating maximum sparkle.

Classic halos work beautifully with virtually any center stone shape—round, oval, cushion, emerald, or fancy cuts. You can opt for a single halo or go more dramatic with a double halo. The versatility is part of why this style has remained popular for over 15 years.

Classic halos are perfect for brides who:

• Love maximum sparkle and presence
• Want their ring noticed across the room
• Are drawn to vintage-inspired or romantic aesthetics
• Want to make a smaller center stone look more substantial
• Appreciate traditional, feminine jewelry design

What Is a Hidden Halo?

A hidden halo takes a completely different approach. Instead of surrounding the center stone where everyone can see it, the diamonds are set underneath the stone in the basket or on the sides of the setting. From the top view, your ring looks like a clean solitaire or simple setting. But tilt your hand, and suddenly there's a secret sparkle that only you (and those close to you) can see.

Hidden halos emerged around 2018 as the minimalist aesthetic took hold in engagement ring design. Brides who wanted something special but didn't want an overtly "blingy" look found the perfect compromise in this subtle detail.

The beauty of a hidden halo is that it adds dimension and sparkle without changing the essential character of your ring. Your center stone remains the star of the show from every angle, but you get that little extra something that makes you smile every time you catch a glimpse of it.

Hidden halos are ideal for brides who:

• Prefer understated elegance over maximum sparkle
• Want a modern, minimalist aesthetic
• Love having a "secret" detail that feels personal
• Gravitate toward clean lines and simple silhouettes
• Want the versatility of a solitaire with something extra

The Longevity Test: How Each Style Ages

Here's where we get to the heart of the matter. Both styles are beautiful when they're brand new, but how do they hold up over time? Let me break down what we've observed with rings that are 5, 10, even 15 years old.

Classic Halo After 5-10 Years

The advantages:

Classic halos have genuine staying power. They've been popular since the early 2010s, which means we now have over 15 years of real-world data on how they age. The good news? Most age beautifully. The style still reads as "timeless elegance" rather than dated trend.

From a practical standpoint, those small halo diamonds actually help hide normal wear on the prongs. When you bring a classic halo in for routine maintenance, any minor issues with the center stone setting are less noticeable because of all that surrounding sparkle. It's also a familiar design to jewelers everywhere, which makes repairs and maintenance straightforward.

Perhaps most importantly, a classic halo still unmistakably looks like an engagement ring. There's no ambiguity, no need to explain. The romantic, substantial presence translates across generations.

The considerations:

That said, certain classic halo styles can feel dated—particularly the very ornate, heavily decorated versions from 2012-2015. If your halo features extremely thick bands with micropavé running everywhere, split shanks, and double halos, it may look distinctly "of its era" in future photos.

Classic halos also require more maintenance. All those small diamonds mean more prongs that need checking. You'll likely need professional inspections every 6-12 months. The intricate design also means more tiny crevices where lotion, soap, and daily grime can accumulate, requiring more frequent professional cleanings.

Resizing can be challenging (sometimes impossible) depending on how the pavé work wraps around the band. And if you decide later that you want to change the look, you're essentially starting over with a new setting.

Hidden Halo After 5-10 Years

The advantages:

The clean top profile of a hidden halo ages exceptionally well. Because the design is inherently subtle, it doesn't scream "2020s trend" the way some styles do. The minimalist aesthetic has been cycling in and out of fashion for over a century, which suggests these rings will feel current for a long time.

From a practical standpoint, hidden halos are generally easier to resize since the decorative elements are concentrated under the center stone rather than wrapping around the band. The lower profile means less snagging on sweaters, hair, and daily activities. And because there's less surface area collecting dirt and debris, many clients find them easier to keep clean with at-home care.

The considerations:

Here's the honest truth: hidden halos are still too new for us to have decades of data. They've only been popular for about 6-7 years, which means the oldest hidden halos are just now reaching the age where we can assess long-term wear patterns.

What we are seeing: those underneath diamonds take more impact and wear than traditional halo stones. They're closer to your hand, more likely to bump against surfaces, and harder to access for cleaning. The basket setting can loosen over time if not properly maintained.

There's also the "wow factor" consideration. Some clients who chose hidden halos for their subtlety later wish they'd gone with something more substantial. The "secret sparkle" that felt special at first sometimes leads to upgrade desires as tastes change.

Which Style Actually Holds Up Better? The Honest Answer

After working with hundreds of couples in Sandy Springs and across Atlanta, here's what I can tell you: both styles hold up well structurally when crafted with quality materials and expert construction. The difference isn't really about durability—it's about how you feel when you look at your ring in 10, 20, or 30 years.

From a Durability Perspective

Both classic and hidden halos are equally durable when properly made. The quality of the metalwork, the precision of the setting, and the craftsmanship matter far more than which style you choose. We've seen poorly made solitaires fall apart and beautifully crafted double halos last for generations.

That said, hidden halos do take more direct wear since those diamonds sit closer to your hand and are more exposed to impact. Classic halos need more frequent prong checks because there are simply more prongs to maintain. It's a trade-off, not a clear winner.

From an Aesthetic Perspective

This is where it gets interesting. Classic halos hit their "peak trend" around 2012-2015. At this point, they've transitioned from "trendy" to "classic." Most people see a well-designed classic halo and think "timeless elegance," not "oh, that's so 2012."

Hidden halos are still too new to judge definitively. However, minimalism as an aesthetic tends to age well across design disciplines—architecture, fashion, furniture. Simple, clean lines rarely look dated because they're not trying to be of-the-moment in the first place.

Here's something I've learned from designing engagement rings since 1998: you can always identify the era when you look closely, but great design transcends its moment. A beautifully proportioned classic halo from 2012 still looks gorgeous. A thoughtfully designed hidden halo from 2020 will likely still look modern in 2040.

From a Value Perspective

Let's talk about resale and trade-in, since this matters to some couples. Both styles retain value based primarily on the quality of the center diamond and the precious metal weight. The style itself has minimal impact on resale value.

Classic halos are easier to sell on the secondary market simply because more people recognize and appreciate the style. Hidden halos appeal to a more specific buyer who values that particular aesthetic. For custom pieces like ours, the craftsmanship and design story often matter more than the trending style.

If you're thinking about eventual upgrades, both styles can be modified—though classic halos typically require more extensive reworking.

What We Recommend to Our Sandy Springs Clients

When couples come into our showroom asking for guidance on this decision, I always start with the same question: "When you imagine yourself wearing this ring every single day for the rest of your life, what do you see?"

Your answer to that question matters more than any trend forecast I could give you.

Choose a Classic Halo If:

• You genuinely love sparkle and presence—not because it's "what engagement rings should look like," but because it makes your heart happy
• You're drawn to romantic, vintage-inspired aesthetics in other areas of your life (your home, your fashion, your Instagram saves)
• You want a ring that clearly announces "I'm engaged" from across the room
• You're not particularly trend-conscious and don't worry about whether something might look "dated" later
• You've looked at rings from the 2010s and still find them beautiful (this is a great test of your personal taste)
• You want to maximize the visual impact of your center stone, especially if you're working with a smaller diamond or lab-grown stone

Choose a Hidden Halo If:

• You prefer subtle, sophisticated details over obvious sparkle
• You gravitate toward minimalist aesthetics in other aspects of your life
• You love the idea of a "secret" that only you and your partner know about
• You want the versatility to dress your ring up or down depending on the setting
• You tend to prefer understated elegance over bold statements in your personal style
• You want a clean top profile that works well with wedding bands and stacking rings

Or Consider a Hybrid Approach

One of the advantages of custom design is that you're not limited to either/or choices. We frequently create rings that combine elements of both styles:

• A thin, delicate classic halo with a hidden halo underneath for extra dimension
• A hidden halo with a few accent stones on the band for additional sparkle
• A partial halo (three-quarters or half) with hidden accent diamonds

These hybrid designs give you the best of both worlds and often age beautifully because they're so personalized to your specific preferences.

The Third Option: Skip the Halo Entirely

Before we conclude, I'd be remiss not to mention that many of our most satisfied clients choose neither a classic nor a hidden halo. A beautifully designed solitaire or three-stone ring offers its own kind of timeless appeal.

Solitaires have been popular for over a century because they:

• Showcase the true beauty and quality of your center diamond without distraction
• Require minimal maintenance over the decades
• Never look dated or "of their era"
• Offer maximum versatility for adding wedding bands and anniversary bands later
• Allow the diamond to be the star, which matters when you've invested in a quality stone

Other alternatives that age beautifully include cathedral settings (elegant architectural details without extra diamonds), pavé bands (sparkle without a halo), and bezel settings (modern, protective, and increasingly popular).

Questions to Ask Yourself Before Deciding

If you're still uncertain which direction to go, try asking yourself these questions:

1. Do you want your ring noticed across the room, or do you prefer subtle sophistication that reveals itself up close? Be honest about your personality and style preferences.
2. How do you feel about maintenance appointments every 6-12 months? If you're busy or tend to forget these things, a lower-maintenance design might suit your lifestyle better.
3. When you imagine your ring in 20 years, what do you see? Close your eyes and picture yourself at your child's wedding or your retirement party. What's on your finger?
4. Do you care if people can "date" your ring to this era? Some people love having a ring that captures their moment in time. Others prefer something more timeless.
5. Look at engagement rings from past decades—what still appeals to you? This is one of the best tests of your personal taste. If you love Art Deco rings from the 1920s or elegant solitaires from the 1950s, you have good instincts for timeless design.
6. Are you risk-averse or trend-embracing in other areas of your life? Your engagement ring decision often mirrors your general approach to style and change.

Our Expert Perspective After 25+ Years

Here's what I've learned after creating custom engagement rings in Sandy Springs since 1998: The rings that age best are the ones designed for the wearer, not for the trend.

I've watched engagement ring trends cycle through three-stone settings, tension settings, rose gold resurgences, and now halos of every variety. The common thread among the clients who return years later still in love with their rings? They chose based on personal style and genuine preference, not on what was popular that year.

We've had brides who chose ultra-trendy designs in 2005 return asking to redesign because the style no longer feels like "them." And we've had clients who chose classic designs in 2000 still wearing and loving their rings without any desire to change a thing.

The truth is, both hidden and classic halos can be absolutely timeless when they're right for you. Focus on these factors instead:

• Quality of craftsmanship: A beautifully made ring in any style will age better than a poorly constructed one
• Proportions suited to your hand: The right scale matters more than the specific style
• Your genuine emotional response: Do you light up when you see it? That feeling is what makes a ring timeless
• The story behind it: Custom designs that reflect your relationship often mean more over time

Whether you choose a classic halo for its romantic sparkle, a hidden halo for its subtle elegance, or something entirely different, what matters most is that your ring reflects your love story and your personal aesthetic.

See Both Halo Styles in Person at Our Sandy Springs Showroom

Trying to decide between hidden and classic halos based on photos and descriptions is challenging. The best way to know which style suits you is to see them in person, try them on, and observe how they look on your hand with your lifestyle.

At Farsi Jewelers, we specialize in custom engagement ring design, which means we can show you both styles and help you understand which best suits your hand shape, lifestyle, and personal aesthetic. We can also create unique hybrid designs that incorporate the elements you love from both approaches.

Schedule your complimentary consultation to:

• Try on examples of both classic and hidden halo styles
• Discuss your vision with our GIA Graduate Gemologist
• Explore lab-grown and natural diamond options
• Learn about custom design possibilities specific to your preferences
• Get honest, pressure-free feedback on what works for your hand and lifestyle

We've been creating custom engagement rings for Sandy Springs and Atlanta couples since 1998. Our goal isn't to sell you what's trending—it's to help you create a ring you'll still love in 2050.

Ready to start designing your perfect engagement ring? Contact us today to schedule your appointment. We're located in Sandy Springs and proudly serve couples throughout the greater Atlanta area.

Book Your Consultation